Retail investors and the Stock Market.
Second report by Borsa Italiana on shareholding in Italy.
A conference by Borsa Italiana
Risk taking decreases as diversification increases.
Interest in stock market investments remains stable.
Personal relations play an increasingly important role in deciding how to allocate savings.
The Conference "The retail investor and the stock exchange - Second report on shareholding in Italy" was held today at Palazzo Mezzanotte. Luca Filippa, Alessandra Franzosi and Enrico Pellizzoni (Borsa Italiana-Research & Development) presented the research and discussed its results with Angelo Tantazzi (President of Borsa Italiana), Massimo Capuano (Managing Director of Borsa Italiana), Luigi Spaventa ("Tor Vergata" University of Rome), Massimo Arrighetti (Banca Intesa - Head of Network Division) and Chiara Fornasari (Prometeia-Partner).
At almost three years from the previous survey, Borsa Italiana once again analyses retail investments in the stock market, that since 1999 steadily account for more than 25% of total market capitalisation.
With the technical support of Doxa, the survey was conducted during the period from December 2003 to January 2004, via personal interviews with families who invest in stocks; in other words, with those who have directly held, purchased or sold shares of publicly traded Italian companies during the period 2001 - 2003.
The number of families in Italy who invest in listed Italian stocks amounts to 3 million, equal to 14% of Italian families.
In an international comparison, Italy stands out as having a good level of equity investment by retail investors and further potential for growth.
Financial assets held by Italian families amounted to over 2,900 billion Euros at the end of 2003, a substantial figure when compared to countries similar to Italy in terms of population, GDP and financial-welfare system.
Financial assets in Italy exceed 300% of disposable income, on the same level with France and Sweden and higher than Germany (270%).
The savings rate in Italy, although significantly reduced (from 20% to 15% during the period 1997-2003), remains one of the highest internationally and contributes to increasing the stock of financial assets.
During the three-year period 2001-2003, approximately 3 million Italian families (14% of the total) invested in listed stocks. This is a significant figure but, in an international comparison, it highlights the potential for increased shareholding in the future: in France, 16% of the population holds stocks directly; in the United Kingdom, the figure rises to 22% and in the United States to 23.9%.
At the end of 2003, listed stocks (national and foreign) accounted for 7.4% of the total financial assets of Italian families. This figure is in line with other countries, except for the United States and Sweden, which have significantly higher values (11.3% and 17.2%, respectively). To a much greater degree than happens in other countries, in Italy families tend to invest in the stock market directly (only an additional 3.7% is attributable to mutual equity funds).
The Italian stock market is thus characterised by a higher level of retail investors (greater than 25% of capitalisation and among the highest levels internationally) and a lower level of institutional investors.
Reference context and propensity to risk
The period under scrutiny (2001-2003) covers a phase of the economic and financial cycle marked by extraordinarily significant events that had a profound effect on the behaviour of Italian investors. In this period the number of families worried about their current financial situation rose from 14% to 27.7% while those worried about their future financial condition rose from 5.3% to 16.1%. The saving capability is viewed as increasingly important (very useful according to 70.3% of interviewees, up from 64.6% in 2001) but also increasingly difficult (families that are able to save drop from 83.2% to 67.3%).
Stock market investors tend to take fewer financial risks. The number of self-defined "conservative investors" is up to 68.8% from 55.2%. Portfolio structures change to reflect the level of perceived (and real) uncertainty in favour of less risky assets whose weight is now up to 58.1% from 45%.
This does not mean that investors are moving away from stocks for good. One out of ten investors did not feel repercussions from stock market fluctuations in the period under survey. Approximately 85% of investors answered that they will be more cautious in the future, but half of these did not change their long term attitude towards investing in stocks. Only one out of twenty interviewees declared they will never again invest in stocks.
There is a high degree of uncertainty. 47.3% of investors do not intend to make additional changes to the asset allocation of their portfolio in the short term and 39.6% do not know what to do.
Portfolios and trading activity
Direct stock market investment absorbs approximately 25% of the total assets of investors, almost a third if equity mutual funds are included. Close to 40% of the investor portfolio is kept liquid, government securities and corporate bonds (including mutual funds) account for 20% and insurance products and pension funds account for 7%. Since 2001 there has been a move away from stocks and managed assets towards less risky and more simple products.
90.3% of Italian stock market investors have Blue Chip stocks in their portfolio. The average portfolio is highly concentrated: 51% have just one stock and almost 24% have two stocks.
Almost 40% of the investors interviewed bought their shares following privatisations. Approximately 6% hold stock that has been bought at the initial public offering of private companies.
Investor activity is down. Since 2001 there has been a significant increase in those who did not make a single trade in the preceding 12 month period (up to 66.9% from 26.6%). Investors who traded did so less often (an average of 12,4 trades/year as compared to 18.1 trades/year the previous survey).
Reasons for investing
57% of interviewees state they invest to improve the yield on their portfolio with respect to staying liquid. 30.8% wish to diversify their investments and 23.7% want to hedge against inflation.
Compared to 2001 there is an increase in medium-term objectives/requirements such as saving to secure the family future, for retirement, to buy a house. Stock market investments in fact do not reflect these requirements, generally associated with shorter term expectations such as quick profits.
Increasingly, stock market investments are viewed as a means of portfolio diversification, a requirement which went up from 23.8% to 34.4% over the last three years. The "play" aspect of investing in the stock market is no longer as strong as it was.
Brokers and sources of information
Banks are the main reference point in the decision to invest, as mentioned by 95% of interviewees: 76.4% mention traditional banks, 29.9% agents, 8.7% online channels. Insurance companies are mentioned by 7.5% of investors and the Post Office by 4.2%. Despite a low level of satisfaction investors tend to resist change in their relation with brokers: the situation is almost unchanged from 2001 and only 5.9% of the interviewees changed their main broker in the last three years. Brokers are chosen out of habit (48.6%) or because of a contact with a person within the organisation (45.1%).
The most critical aspects are commissions and costs (36.9% of interviewees express dissatisfaction), yields on investments (27.1%), the availability of updated and complete information (13.3%) and broker independence (11.1%).
Among the sources of information there is a significant increase in personal relationships, mentioned by 77.8% of interviewees against 60% in 2001. These are bank employees (41.5%), family and friends (34.7%), and agents (29.9%). Other sources of information are less consulted with respect to the previous survey. 53.2% of the interviewees mention the press (30.4% the general press, 28.9% financial newspapers and 12.7% financial magazines) against 65.2% in 2001, with a marked reduction in the financial press (in 2001 42.8% of interviewees mentioned financial newspapers as a source of information and 19.8% mentioned financial magazines).
29.9% use TV/radio as a source of information (especially teletext - 16.3%). 15.3% mention Internet.
The type of information consists mainly in investment advice from experts or friends (52.4%) rather than editorials or articles on company performance (31%), price charts (21.3%), macroeconomic forecasts (17%), financial statements (12.6%) or analyst reports (9.2%).
More than one third of those who invest in stocks make an independent decision on how to invest without soliciting outside advice, down from 45.7% in 2001. But the remaining prefer to decide for themselves after consulting their broker (up from 23% to 38.2%) rather than delegate someone else to make the decision for them.
There is still significant room for improving the financial education and awareness of retail investors. Uncertainty about basic notions is widespread and only 3% of investors took courses in finance. Only 40.4% say they know the difference between listed and unlisted instruments.
The socio-demographic characteristics of retail investors
Stock market investors form a cluster both with respect to the Italian population and to investors in general. They are:
More affluent: 51.1% have an average monthly income over 2,300 Euros, against 26.5% of the population; 66.7% have assets valued over 15,000 Euro against 32.3% of the population; 91.3% of the interviewees own real estate against 72% of the Italian population.
Milan, November 25th, 2004
The Exchange accepts no responsability for the content of the website you are now accessing or for any reliance placed by you or any person on the information contained on it.
By allowing this link the Exchange does not intend in any country, directly or indirectly, to solicit business or offer any securities to any person.
You will be redirected in five seconds.